yearlystorage .com
Lowest 12-month rent

Cheapest self-storage in Indianapolis, IN

These 28 facilities have the lowest listed monthly rents in Indianapolis right now, sorted by 12-month rent (listed monthly rate × 12). Move-in promos are shown separately as badges — the table uses the ongoing street rate where we can detect it.

28 Matching facilities
$30 Lowest listed /mo
$360 Lowest 12-mo rent
$51 Median /mo

12-month rent = listed monthly rate × 12. For admin fees, insurance, rate increases, and prepay vs month-to-month paths, use the all-in cost calculator.

Results

Facilities in Indianapolis

All Indianapolis facilities →

Public Storage

749 Beachway Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46224, USA · 5.9 mi

Listed from
$30
/ month
Discount 50% Book online Climate control Drive-up
9 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $360

Extra Space Storage

675 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA · < 1 mi

Listed from
$30
/ month
First-month special First month free Move-in special Climate control
7 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $360

Signature Self Storage

3214 E Thompson Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46227, USA · 5.7 mi

Listed from
$34
/ month
First-month special Discount 50% Prepay option Admin fee waived Book online Climate control Drive-up
2 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $408

StoreEase Self Storage

6550 S Belmont Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46217, USA · 7.2 mi

Listed from
$34
/ month
First-month special Discount 30% Climate control Drive-up
3 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $408

Extra Space Storage

501 Fulton St, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA · < 1 mi

Listed from
$34
/ month
Climate control
9 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $408

Signature Self Storage

9750 N Michigan Rd, Carmel, IN 46032, USA · 11.7 mi

Listed from
$36
/ month
First-month special Discount 50% Admin fee waived Book online Climate control Drive-up
2 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $432

CubeSmart Self Storage

2135 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA · 1.9 mi

Listed from
$37
/ month
Move-in special Discount 40% Book online Climate control Drive-up
26 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $444

Bigger Garage Self-Storage

4841 Industrial Pkwy, Lawrence, IN 46226, USA · 9.1 mi

Listed from
$39
/ month
Book online Drive-up
6 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $468

Signature Self Storage

8050 Ortho Ln, Brownsburg, IN 46112, USA · 12.1 mi

Listed from
$39
/ month
Move-in special Discount 50% Admin fee waived Book online Climate control Drive-up
2 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $468

Signature Self Storage

765 W Carmel Dr, Carmel, IN 46032, USA · 13.7 mi

Listed from
$44
/ month
First-month special Discount 50% Admin fee waived Book online Climate control Drive-up
2 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $528

Public Storage

4350 S East St, Indianapolis, IN 46227, USA · 4.6 mi

Listed from
$48
/ month
Climate control Drive-up
5 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $576

Beech Grove Self Storage

5832 Churchman Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203, USA · 6.3 mi

Listed from
$50
/ month
Book online Drive-up
2 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $600

Menards Self Storage Carmel

2484 147th St, Carmel, IN 46033, USA · 16.3 mi

Listed from
$50
/ month
Climate control
2 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $600

Carmel Drive Self Storage

550 W Carmel Dr, Carmel, IN 46032, USA · 13.5 mi

Listed from
$52
/ month
Book online Climate control Drive-up
14 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $624

Store Space Self Storage

2715 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46225, USA · 2.8 mi

Listed from
$53
/ month
First-month special First month free Discount 50% Book online Climate control
12 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $636

Public Storage

8525 Castleton Square Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46250, USA · 11.1 mi

Listed from
$54
/ month
Discount 50% Book online Climate control Drive-up
8 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $648

Store Space Self Storage

1426 W 29th St, Indianapolis, IN 46208, USA · 3.2 mi

Listed from
$55
/ month
First-month special First month free Discount 50% Book online Climate control
9 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $660

BLC Self Storage

4001 E US Hwy 40, Greenfield, IN 46140, USA · 23.0 mi

Listed from
$60
/ month
3 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $720

CubeSmart Self Storage

1998 Conner St, Noblesville, IN 46060, USA · 21.0 mi

Listed from
$64
/ month
First-month special First month free Discount 40% Military / student / senior Book online Drive-up
3 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $768

Self-Storage at U-Haul

2960 Lafayette Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46222, USA · 4.4 mi

Listed from
$65
/ month
Book online Climate control
4 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $779

Self-Storage at U-Haul

1430 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA · 1.2 mi

Listed from
$70
/ month
Climate control
8 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $839

Store Space Self Storage

2455 Central Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205, USA · 2.4 mi

Listed from
$72
/ month
First-month special First month free Discount 50% Climate control
8 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $864

Public Storage

933 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA · < 1 mi

Listed from
$82
/ month
Discount 50% Climate control Drive-up
8 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $984

Self-Storage at U-Haul

7027 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46250, USA · 11.6 mi

Listed from
$85
/ month
Book online Climate control Drive-up
7 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $1,019

Self-Storage at U-Haul

6014 Michigan Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46228, USA · 6.9 mi

Listed from
$130
/ month
Admin fee waived Book online Climate control
2 unit price s listed 12-mo rent $1,559

Lynhurst Self Storage

5051 W Bradbury Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46241, USA · 5.3 mi

Listed from
$138
/ month
1 unit price listed 12-mo rent $1,656
More in Indianapolis

Other long-term storage guides

10×10 units 17 facilities Climate-controlled 21 facilities Rate-lock language Browse → Annual prepay 1 facilities All facilities 78 in Indianapolis

Indianapolis is the practical pick: stable rents, generous units for the money, and a steady pipeline of relocations from the surrounding Midwest. Less seasonal swing than the Sun Belt metros.

Model the true all-in cost

Listed rent × 12 is a starting point. The calculator adds rate increases, admin fees, optional protection, and compares month-to-month vs prepay vs rate-lock over 12–36 months.